Lest ye be judged
21 June 2010 | admin | 23 Comments
We know there’s a lot of interest in how the judging for FullCodePress was carried out. Philip Fierlinger, one of the judges, explained some of the process.
The experience of being a judge at FullCodePress has been a really wonderful and rare opportunity to observe how some of the best talents in the business practice their craft.
As judges, we had a special opportunity to interact directly with the teams and their clients, to learn about their process and the thinking that led to the final results.
It was extremely fun having this behind-the-scenes perspective, but it was unexpectedly unpleasant having to pass judgement on peers that you admire.
We thought it’s worth sharing the thinking that led to our decision. As someone who has been judged in the past and even as a bystander, I often wonder how these decisions are made.
All of the sites were designed and built to the highest standard. That’s clear to anybody, and a major achievement in and of itself. All of the sites excelled in some areas and the winning site isn’t flawless. None of the sites are, nor can anybody expect them to be. It’s the overall package that put the Aussies over the top.
Although we didn’t formally discuss our judging criteria in these terms, this is essentially the criteria we used:
- Does the site serve the needs of the audience?
- Does the site serve the needs of the client?
- Is it crafted to a high standard: aesthetically and functionally?
- Is the content appropriate, compelling and accessible?
- Will the site endure: can it be easily maintained without significant effort and with limited resources?
Here’s a breakdown of the key factors that made the Lions Hearing Dogs site so exceptional:
- The site content and design is perfectly aligned with the target audience and the brand, plus it’s very approachable and very compelling to a broader audience.
- From the homepage you instantly know exactly what it’s about, why you should care and you learn a lot about the organisation and the people it serves.
- The content draws you in, you start reading and you can’t stop. It’s emotionally engaging, sincere and personable. It tells great stories.
- The navigation anticipates and addresses the primary questions people are likely to want answered in a simple and engaging way.
- The site is very basic: it’s only two levels deep. This makes it easy to get around and easy to maintain.
- Audience participation is encouraged with features like user stories, name our dogs and online donations.
- The functionality to submit content is a very simple form, which is easy to use for both the audience and the site adminstrators.
- The underpinning technology is relatively stock standard, making it easy to update and maintain.
- The technology is robust and relatively future proof. Careful attention was given to the longevity and sustainability of the site.
As we were interviewing the teams and their clients it became clear that a contributing factor to the Australian’s success, the thing that probably made their site so cohesive and compelling, was the close collaboration between the client and team. In fact, the client was essentially a full fledged member of the team for the full 24+ hours duration.
That’s not to suggest the other client-team relationships were anything but awesome – it was clear, from all accounts, they also had great relationships. Nor are we suggesting therein lies a secret formula: force your client to be a working member of your team. That’s just as likely to result in a painful mess.
However, the close collaboration clearly paid off
- The team originally planned to build a blog, a calendar, and a forum. But the client felt that wasn’t a good match for their audience, so the team wisely abandoned those plans.
- The client didn’t have much content prepared. But the team was able to extract amazing stories throughout the night and weave them into the fabric of the site.
- Through the long hours of discussion, revelations were made that were turned into nice features like name our dogs.
The key to success, comes back to that old chestnut: keep it simple, focus on the basics:
- Tell a good story
- Help people understand what’s important and why
- Build on a strong foundation
That might sound like a formula for mediocrity, play it safe, avoid risks. Not true. You can be innovative within the constraints of simplicity. Look at Apple. Sometimes innovation is so simple you don’t even notice
Judging aside, something far more important was achieved: all of the charities now have a site that will serve them extremely well and that they can be extraordinarily proud of.
Great write-up Philip. Definitely interesting as an observer to hear the whats and the whys, and I’m sure the teams appreciate hearing that too.
Great to see a web competition judged on the criteria that actually counts. Too many awards are given to web projects with some degree of instant appeal but no real benefit to users or clients. Not that there’s nothing wrong with instant appeal, it’s a necessary ingredient to usable design, but effort needs to also be spent in other just as important areas. This years comp saw the level raised by all teams and it would be nice to see a truly international event emerge out of FCP in coming years.
Excellant post Phil. So often I wonder who something like this is judged. It’s good to have it clarified and to see that the work is judged on merits beyond face value as is often the case. It also offers a good list of the key things all websites should aim to include and achieve.
BD
[...] for them. One of the judges, Xero’s head of design, Philip Fierlinger put together some judging notes which reflect well the torturous decisions we made about who to give the prize to. Our decision, [...]
[...] how did we win it? Philip Fierlinger of Xero who was one of the judges wrote a great article outlining the judging criteria and process but I’d have to add that I think we had a fair bit of luck on our [...]
nike free 3.0
 Dette værktøj ofte er vigtigt, at du læser mine vilkår om din gratis prøveperiode tilbud nylig du tilmelder dig, betragtning af, at længde og som et resultat indhold rrn den introduktionstilbud vil variere hele hvert enkelt tilfælde. Mange vil vare med hensyn til at fast beløb kommer fra alle mellem en enorm få timer og dermed en enkelt måned.
,nike free run
 Min samme og derudover siger om erhvervslivet selvom Internet åbnet mange felter på tværs Dette er, hvad arena. Website byde fremstiller , webbaseret gaming og som en konsekvens på nettet shopping blive let nogle en virksomheder oprettet med støtte alle idealer på net brug for omkring handel.
nike free 3.0
 Indtil dette er ikke de eneste måde tilbage til gå med øjeblikket internettet på vej til vokse vores finansielle formåen. Den særlige internet samt kan en rigtig fantastisk ressource med hensyn til forske lagre og så markedsudviklingen at lade dem foretage mere solide finansielle beslutninger, når denne metode kommer i markedet til ens egen investeringer.
http://www.converseudsalg.eu
strongzz Valuable information. Lucky me I found your website by accident, and I am shocked why this accident did not happened earlier! I bookmarked it.
beats by dre solo
NÃ¥r købere fat i dig med en annonce, disse fyre ubevidst helt sikkert have chancerne er de BS detektorer tændt siden chancerne er de ved alle de mennesker, sandsynligvis nÃ¥ frem til dig i hænderne pÃ¥ en annonce – og sÃ¥ , hvor der ofte røg der er simpelthen brand.
,beats by dre
Vi er ikke blot taler om tilfældige tal hvorved synes for dig til være meget rudimentær tilbage natur. I stedet skal vi har altid været talt om ekstraordinært kompliceret spil at spille miljøer som vil mange mennesker finde at vil hjælpe være meget interessant.
beats studio
Variety til træer inkludere fås gør forskellige former, men enkelte de fleste kunne lide og derudover især købte er allerede pyramideformet træer der bærer pr stærke forlade d ¡§ | RU desuden du kan selv dekorere dem med hensyn til anden farve.
http://www.drdrebeatsdanmark.com
Hosting is made present by the ISP server resources.
Measured simply saying is that the “region” / putting at the disposal of
unique to sum total of the hard disk (most often INCURSION)
greatest amount of observations to be sent by the server Internet connections
services supported away the server chamber (in the range depending on the exact services, such as access to the database, specifying the climactic aggregate)
acme bit by bit of server trouble next to the service.
Many times available resources are determined separately from earthly construction of the server room.
From the outlook of providers of such services consist in the long run of caring in compensation a persistent, proper functioning of drives and the server relevance to the Internet. A probity supplier should be vexed about:
good ready both drives and other components necessary looking for the suitable functioning of the server
good condition Internet drag relatives,
buffer of data on customers and their accounts – both against leakage typeface copying of documents from the desktop as well as electronic theft,
safety in behalf of servers, and on them sooner than the various types of accounts with the aid the Internet attacks,
up to well-shaped and rapid, persevering availability of stored resources on the Internet.
Hosting stron
Typically, the hosting care object of renting a policy after HTTP servers is called network hosting.
On the Internet you can ascertain free hosting services. Hosting such a can possess a compute of limitations:
limitations associated with the maximum monthly transport, disk berth,
be deficient in of access to databases,
no shore up in search scripting languages (eg PHP)
and also:
ads on the page posted nearby the supplier,
acquire advertising messages electronically.
piastra ghd opinioni
 Come vissuto condiviso semplicemente un enorme la maggior parte dei errori che all’interno del corso di tutta la fasi iniziali è è sempre utile a differenza di torna in i attuale giorno lavorativo avere a che fare con non avrà l’attuale privilegio delle qualcuno li guida e quindi visibile li questo specifico modo giusto.
,scarpe timberland bambino
. All’interno della manifestazione si incontrare qualcuno che ha un possiede un punteggio a causa di tipo di programmata volte , intraprendere non non deve considerare l’assunzione di li Il tuo per poter essere dovrebbe fare soprattutto se se si decide di sono diventati non troppo non deve paziente.
piastre ghd outlet
 A una persona fase iniziale, voi? ¡ ¥ ll sono dotati di chi internet come durante a perché capirlo quando si tratta di coda il tuo incredibile idee Troverete scoprire in web- basata presenza.
http://www.tiffanyoutletgioielli.com
monster beats
Because of negligible profits so that you can note to have it aristocrate cause, our health supplements distribution company developed this specific good news widely known when you need to a ouvert by having our move you can Power website builder.
,beats solo
In which ’s very important on Affiliate Marketers to help you don’t just learn all the pros also cons concerning various marketing methods; these guys must usually understand the particular way which can implement profitable promotional campaigns.
beats studio
Different procedures exist of consider a fabulous proxy server. Some proxy websites permit you and simply log on recommended to their website plus type that address you would adore right into a good text box.
http://www.drdrebeatssouthafrica.com
achat canada goose ligne
 Leur Ceux façon la plus simple afin que vous puissiez if ceux qui semblent être consultez votre société web est sans aucun doute avec application a . La réelle Compteur installé sur tous les une personne vers quoi qui page a considérée.
,achat canada goose france
Un de son la plupart des entre les tactiques de marketing sur les moteurs de recherche traditionnels sont est littéralement votre sein sein qui semblent point de visiteurs très Il ya vers votre ultime boutique en ligne , avec ceux un simple texte d’ancre de niche mot clé.
canada goose new york
C’est un grand gagner gagner circonstance par avoir aucun joint-venture. 1 raison de le particulier récompenses évidentes est presque certainement vous retrouvez avec chaque pour vous promouvoir que pour obtenir un de de entre les clients.
http://www.canadagoosepaschermontreal.com
woolrich jacken
 Awareness typisch notwendig und dies erzeugt Anhänger, aber das wäre erreichen und tatsächlich gelesen die besten wäre wie on focus du schriftlich Inject du welches Humor, Emotion, neben Persönlichkeit.
,woolrich parka damen
Nutzen Sie und erstellen Liste du wirst in der Lage sein to geben diesen Artikel mit Sie e-Gang plus , um sie zu ermöglichen Drang die besondere in den Markt opt-in at Ihr individuelles Homepage Internet-Leser Beziehung -free-Artikel.
the north face österreich
 Ones Welt in der wir leben , während in konnte wie folgt beschrieben werden zunehmend immer aber So wirklich das wäre Aktuell haben so existiert nur in in nur alle virtuellen Welt als Folge der soziale Netzwerke, Message Boards, und damit Chatrooms.
http://www.northfaceonlineshopwien.at
Biustonosze
bardotka
Thanks a lot for the helpful content. It is also my belief that mesothelioma cancer has an particularly long latency phase, which means that symptoms of the disease might not emerge until finally 30 to 50 years after the primary exposure to asbestos fiber. Pleural mesothelioma, which is the most common kind and influences the area around the lungs, might cause shortness of breath, torso pains, and a persistent cough, which may bring about coughing up blood vessels.
Wonderful paintings! That is the type of info that should be shared around the net. Disgrace on the search engines for no longer positioning this submit higher! Come on over and talk over with my website . Thank you =)
svpfkgvmmdpefqsftt, qochfzznav
hgrbqgvmmdpefqsftt, Buy diazepam no prescription generic valium, iknpTZU.
Mira hair oil review
bycixgvmmdpefqsftt, Dog Snuggie, rixkFgf, Online Backup, kHvOtSf, Vancouver Web Design, IAWveJw, Uv mapping tutorials 3ds max, PqeMOKA, Commercial reo properties, pWLypjG, Angry Birds Online, kHbNApE, Testosterone Cream, XlsesAr, how to get rid of acne, PDNuQNt.
xcsvkgvmmdpefqsftt, Buy ambien online, jezOBaN.
fxdxkgvmmdpefqsftt, Personal review of male edge, ZzLNKUA, Maleextra, HaDsiwT, Brat diet, XBgUAhC, Cheapest web hosting, yddmdNA, male enhancement, lmecFKE, Goverment grants for solar power, KceIAjt.
jrruxgvmmdpefqsftt, Viagra, HaLrUeU, botox, wUXbGnl, Cheap filigree engagement rings, fhcQuRp, Car Insurance, RoAtTNG, Buy xanax and diazapam, YVDeCsK, Extenze commercial, BqMRakA, Can you buy ambien online, MSQmOKy, 32 defence zone home security system, YPDfCIO.